\(
\def\WIPO{World Intellectual Property Organisation}
\)
Domestic industry: Why the analysis should change with the times
2025
Formats
| Format | |
|---|---|
| BibTeX | |
| MARCXML | |
| TextMARC | |
| MARC | |
| DataCite | |
| DublinCore | |
| EndNote | |
| NLM | |
| RefWorks | |
| RIS | |
Title
Domestic industry: Why the analysis should change with the times
Author
Item Type
Journal article
Description
1 online resource
Note
In 2023, there were 516,427 U.S. patent applications, 848,945 trademark filings, and 69,364 industrial design applications. While there are many forums in which to assert Intellectual Property rights, the United States International Trade Commission (hereinafter, the “ITC” or “Commission”) is one of the most popular. The ITC, however, faces a dilemma. Section 337 requires that the complainant prove there is an industry in the United States related to articles protected by the asserted IP rights. This domestic industry requirement has two aspects--the technical prong and the economic prong. The technical prong requires that the so-called domestic industry products utilize the asserted IP rights. The economic prong-- the focus of this Note--requires that there is, in the United States, with respect to the domestic industry products, (a) significant investments in plant and equipment, (b) significant employment of labor or capital, or (c) substantial investment in exploitation of the asserted IP right, including engineering, research, development, or licensing. But since the enactment of § 337 as part of the Tariff Act of 1930, a disagreement has emerged about which categories of investments should count toward the economic prong. Currently, among the ITC commissioners, there is a lack of consensus as to what types of investments made by the complainant should count as part of the domestic industry. Some *621 commissioners follow the “line-by-line” approach, which considers each and every claimed expense, discards those deemed equivalent to the types of expenses made by a “mere importer,” and determines whether the remaining expenses are sufficient to establish a domestic industry. Other commissioners follow the “as-a-whole” approach, which takes a more holistic look at whether the petitioner has established a domestic industry related to the patented article.10 This Note seeks to investigate how we arrived at this dilemma, and how the ITC should solve it.
Source of Description
Crossref
Series
AIPLA Quarterly Journal, Fall 2025, Volume 53, Issue 4, p. 619.
Linked Resources
Published
[New York, NY] : Thomson Reuters, 2025.
Language
English
Copyright Information
https://1.next.westlaw.com/Copyright
Record Appears in